There's no single "best" pet insurance — but there IS a best policy for your pet. We compared Australia's leading cover types on limits, benefits, exclusions and claims experience to crown our 2026 winners.

Our 2026 winners 🥇

🏆 Best overall

Pawtect Comprehensive Plus

$15k annual limit, 80% benefit, hereditary cover included and gap-only payments direct to your vet. The policy we would buy for our own pets.

Visit partner →
💰 Best value

AussiePaws Accident + Illness

$12k limit and 80% benefit at one of the lowest monthly premiums we found. No wellness fluff — just solid cover.

Visit partner →
🐣 Best for puppies & kittens

FurSure Young Pet Plan

Short waiting periods, desexing benefit in year one and a multi-pet discount. See our puppy insurance guide.

Visit partner →
👴 Best for seniors

VetSure Lifetime

No upper age limit on existing policies and chronic condition cover that renews every year. See our senior dog guide.

Visit partner →

The comparison table 📊

PartnerAnnual limitBenefitHereditary coverGap paymentZookie score
🐾 Pawtect Top pick$15,00080%✅ Included✅ Yes★★★★★ 9.4Visit →
AussiePaws$12,00080%✅ Included❌ No★★★★☆ 8.7Visit →
FurSure$10,00070–80%✅ Included❌ No★★★★☆ 8.2Visit →
VetSure$15,00075%⚠️ Sub-limits✅ Yes★★★★☆ 7.9Visit →
CuddlesCover$8,00080%⚠️ Sub-limits❌ No★★★☆☆ 7.1Visit →

How we score policies 🔬

  • Annual limit (25%) — $10k minimum; $15k+ scores best.
  • Benefit percentage (15%) — 80% is the sweet spot.
  • Hereditary & chronic cover (20%) — the make-or-break for purebreds. Check your breed's risks in our insurance-by-breed guides.
  • Exclusions & sub-limits (20%) — we penalise sneaky caps on skin, dental and cruciate claims.
  • Claims experience (20%) — gap-only payments, pre-approval and processing speed.

How to choose in 60 seconds ✅

Key takeaways ✅

  • ✓Best overall: strong accident + illness, $15k limit, gap payments.
  • ✓Match the policy to your breed's known risks.
  • ✓Compare sub-limits and exclusions — not just the monthly price.